Which payroll software tool fits you?
Answer a few questions and get a ranked recommendation, computed from our maintained pricing & feature dataset — not a paid placement.
ToolFit may earn a commission when you sign up through some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This never affects our rankings — those come straight from the dataset. Full affiliate disclosure.
As of 2026-08-19, for a very small workforce focused on automated payroll, our top pick is Gusto — Full payroll automation support; From $35/mo on the cheapest priced option. Change the answers above to re-rank for your situation.
- From $35/mo
- Covers: Payroll automation, Tax filing, Benefits and HR, Contractor support
- small businesssolopreneurs & beginners
- From $39/mo
- Covers: Payroll automation, Tax filing, Benefits and HR, Contractor support
- small businesssolopreneurs & beginners
- From $49/mo
- Covers: Payroll automation, Tax filing, Benefits and HR, Contractor support
- small businessrestaurantsnonprofits
- From $50/mo
- Covers: Payroll automation, Tax filing, Benefits and HR, Contractor support
- small business
No tool matches every filter — try relaxing the budget or the free-plan requirement.
The picks, side by side
| Tool | Free plan | Starts at | Priced options | Best for | Visit site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto | ✗ | $35/mo | 4 | small business solopreneurs & beginners | Visit site → |
| SurePayroll | ✗ | $39/mo | 1 | small business solopreneurs & beginners | Visit site → |
| OnPay | ✗ | $49/mo | 1 | small business restaurants nonprofits | Visit site → |
| Justworks | ✗ | $50/mo | 1 | small business | Visit site → |
Sources: gusto.com/product/pricing, verified · surepayroll.com/pricing, verified · onpay.com/payroll/software/accountants/pricing, verified · justworks.com/pricing, verified
Get notified when prices change
We track payroll software pricing daily. Get an email the moment a tool's price changes — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.